UNLV Boyd Law Blog

Admissions | Academics | Centers and Programs | Faculty | Careers | Library


UNLV Boyd Law Blog

An online community for collaboration on legal policy, practice and academics

Showing posts with label Patent Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Patent Law. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 25, 2015

Ms. Betty Willis: Her Famous “Welcome to Fabulous Las Vegas” Sign and Her Artistic Legacy in Las Vegas Neon

Photo (c) 2015 Gary A. Trimble
On March 23, 2015, Ms. Marjorie Holland, the daughter of Ms. Betty Willis, visited the Boyd School of Law to speak to Boyd students, faculty, and guests about her mother, a beloved artist who shaped the history of Las Vegas neon sign design. Ms. Willis, now 91, is most well known for her iconic sign “Welcome to Fabulous Las Vegas,” which she designed in 1959; the sign still welcomes visitors on Las Vegas Boulevard at the south end of the “Strip” today. But Ms. Willis’ legacy includes many other signs, including the famous sign for the Moulin Rouge Casino, which opened in May 1955 as the first desegregated hotel and casino in Las Vegas, and the sign for the Blue Angel Motel.

Photo (c) 2015 Gary A. Trimble
Ms. Holland's talk was co-organized by the Wiener-Rogers Law Library and Professor Marketa Trimble, and gave students from Professor Trimble’s Advanced Intellectual Property Seminar an opportunity to learn about Ms. Willis’ artistic legacy, career, vision, and concerns, and also a practical background for considerations of legal protection and the limitations of legal protection that apply to artists and their art, particularly in the context of art created for public places.

Photo (c) 2015 Gary A. Trimble
The Advanced Intellectual Property Seminar, offered at Boyd each year by either Professor Mary LaFrance or Professor Marketa Trimble, is designed for students who complete at least one of Boyd’s foundational intellectual property law courses and want further specialization in an area of intellectual property law. The Seminar expands students’ knowledge of intellectual property law and policies that affect the law by building on the students’ knowledge from the foundational courses. Students write an extensive research paper for the Seminar that explores an advanced intellectual property law topic of their choice. For example, the students in the Seminar this year are writing research papers covering topics such as the patenting of computer programs, the patenting of financial business methods, the patenting of artificial intelligence, parodies made of fashion brands, copyright and creativity in hip-hop music, and recent amendments to the Korean patent law.

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

Patenting in Nevada (Part 3)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law 

Click on figures to enlarge them
The number of patents granted in a given period for inventions originating in a particular territory is an inaccurate proxy for the innovative activity that occurs in the period and the territory. Patents on inventions considered novel, non-obvious, and useful capture only some of ongoing innovation, and therefore the number of patents granted is only one of several indicators of innovative activity. Fluctuations in the number of patents granted may be associated with a number of factors, including institutional and procedural changes in patent applicants’ organizations and in the Patent Office, and also changes in attitudes in a particular industry toward the protection of inventions by patents. The availability of highly skilled patent attorneys and patent agents who can draft and prosecute patent applications successfully is yet another factor that can affect the number of patents granted.

Keeping the above caveat in mind, we can note that the numbers of U.S. patents granted in 2010 – 2013 on inventions by Nevada inventors indicate a positive trend in innovation in Nevada. (Throughout this post, the terms “patents” and “inventions” are used to refer to utility and design patents and to inventions and designs, and the statistics are for calendar years, not fiscal years.) While Figure 1 shows a slight decrease in the number of patents granted on applications listing Nevada assignees in 2011 and 2012 (when the numbers of such patents granted were in the 1,300s), Figure 1 also shows that in 2013 the number of such patents granted that year jumped to 1,691. Development in Nevada is unequivocally positive in Figure 2, which shows a gradual rise in the number of patents granted on inventions for which at least one inventor was a Nevada resident; the number increased from 794 patents granted in 2010 to 1265 patents granted in 2013.

Figure 3 compares the development of the numbers of all U.S. patents granted in 2010 – 2013 with the development of the numbers of U.S. patents granted on applications listing Nevada assignees and Nevada inventors. The number of all U.S. patents granted in 2013 was 24% higher than it was in 2010; the number of U.S. patents granted in 2013 exceeded 300,000. The number of U.S. patents granted on applications listing Nevada assignees in 2013 was 12% higher than it was in 2010, but there was a slight dip in the numbers in 2011 and 2012. However, patents on applications that named at least one Nevada inventor have been growing steadily from 2010 to 2013, and the number of such patents granted in 2013 was 59% higher than it was in 2010.

The numbers of patents granted could have risen in Nevada because of an increase in Nevada’s population or growth in Nevada’s economy; to find out whether the rise might be attributable to an increase in the intensity of innovation, it is useful to look at the development of the numbers of patents per million Nevada residents and per $ billion Nevada GDP. Figures 4 and 5 show that the numbers of patents on inventions by Nevada inventors, per million Nevada residents and per $ billion Nevada GDP, have been growing, and that they have been growing faster than the numbers of patents on inventions by all U.S. inventors, per million U.S. residents and per $ billion U.S. GDP. In fact, Figure 5 shows that more patents per $ billion Nevada GDP were granted on inventions by Nevada inventors in 2012 and 2013 than were granted on inventions by U.S. inventors per $ billion U.S. GDP in those years.

The increase in the number of patents on inventions by Nevada inventors is confirmed by Figures 6 and 7, which show, per million residents and per $ billion GDP, the number of patents on applications in which a U.S. and a Nevada resident were the first-named inventors. The state or country of residence of the first-named inventor is the criterion that the USPTO uses, for statistical purposes, to define the geographical origin of a patent. Using this definition, Figures 6 and 7 show an increase in the numbers of patents granted on inventions by Nevada inventors, per million Nevada residents and per $ billion Nevada GDP. The numbers of patents granted in 2012 and 2013 on inventions by Nevada residents per million Nevada residents and per $ billion Nevada GDP in Figure 7 do not exceed the U.S.-wide numbers as they do in Figure 5; nevertheless, Figures 4 – 7 all suggest possible intensification of innovation in Nevada.

As noted above, number of patents granted is not the only indicator of innovative activity, and might not even be an accurate predictor of economic development. Much more than patenting must happen to propel economic growth; lawyers who can provide high-quality legal advice and sensible business perspectives are indispensable for the success of innovation. Preparing lawyers who will help sustain and promote innovation in Nevada is one of the Boyd Law School’s most important missions.

The data in Figures 1-7 are from the USPTO Calendar Year Patent Statistics and from data collected with the use of the USPTO Search for Patents.

For previous installments of this blog post chain see Part 1 and Part 2.

Professor Trimble welcomes any citing or quoting of this blog post or reposting of the entire blog post and/or the figures; however, she requests that you cite the author and title of the blog post and include a link to this page.

Monday, November 24, 2014

Nevada Bar Intellectual Property Law Section’s 2014 Annual Conference at Boyd

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law 

On Nov. 14, 2014, the William S. Boyd School of Law co-sponsored and hosted the annual Intellectual Property Law Conference of the Intellectual Property Law Section of the State Bar of Nevada. This is the second year the Law School has hosted the Conference, which offers an excellent opportunity for Section members, the Boyd faculty, and Boyd students to discuss current issues in intellectual property law and network with colleagues sharing common interests.

The program began with two morning sessions presenting an in-depth look at selected problems of franchising and intellectual property licensing. Matthew J. Kreutzer (Howard & Howard, Las Vegas, NV) shared his expertise in franchising, which has evolved over his more than 15 years of working with individuals and companies on franchising relationships. Paul C. Jorgensen (The Jorgensen Law Firm, Washington, D.C.) gave an overview of major issues in licensing and provided valuable practice tips related to drafting and negotiating intellectual property licenses.

The first afternoon session was divided into two tracks. Track One focused on copyright and trademark law; Professor Mary LaFrance and Associate Professor Marketa Trimble, both Boyd faculty members, reviewed recent and current developments in trademark and copyright law from the past year, including U.S. Supreme Court 2014 decisions in these areas. Professor Justin Hughes (Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, CA) spoke on enforcement of intellectual property rights on the Internet and provided a comparative perspective that is useful in an era of Internet and other cross-border intellectual property right disputes. Track Two concentrated on patent law. Herbert R. Schulze (Holland & Hart, Reno, NV) covered the historical development of the law on patentable subject matter and discussed its current trajectory following the heavily criticized June 2014 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l. Juergen Krause-Polstorff (San Jose, CA) addressed current issues in functional claiming, and David C. Van Dyke (Howard & Howard, Chicago, IL) spoke on patent litigation concerning standard essential patents, fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory licensing terms that owners of such patents must offer, and obligations stemming from participation in standard-setting organizations.

The second afternoon session covered a variety of current issues in entertainment law. The panel chair, Ryan R. Gile (Weide & Miller, Ltd., Las Vegas, NV), invited a group of highly experienced local attorneys who generously shared cautionary tales and practice tips spanning privacy law, the right of publicity, employment law, Internet domain name law, professional responsibility, and other areas. The panelists were Anat Levy (Beverly Hills, CA, and Las Vegas, NV), Linda Norcross (‘04, Howard & Howard, Las Vegas, NV), Steven Pacitti (Feldmann Nagel, LLC, Las Vegas, NV), and Kimberly Stein (Howard & Howard, Las Vegas, NV).

The William S. Boyd School of Law is proud to be a co-sponsor of the annual Conference of the Intellectual Property Law Section; Boyd co-sponsorship is one of the many ways the law school connects with the State Bar of Nevada.

Monday, November 10, 2014

Nevada IP Practitioners Share Their Expertise and Enthusiasm with Boyd Students

The most enriching environment for students is one that enables them to learn from both excellent academic faculty and highly experienced practitioners. Boyd students benefit even more when the practitioners are from Nevada and share their observations about practicing law from a Nevada viewpoint. This semester Boyd students benefited from two events that brought an outstanding group of intellectual property (“IP”) law practitioners to Boyd.

The first event, a panel discussion on October 7, 2014, featured three attorneys who practice in Las Vegas; they discussed career options available in the practice of IP law. W. West Allen, a partner at Lewis Rocca Rothgerber, spoke about his role in litigation and his role as adviser to companies on a wide variety of IP matters. Seaton J. Curran, an attorney with Howard & Howard, explained his role in prosecuting patents before the USPTO and foreign patent offices and advising inventors and companies on patent filing issues. Abiola Shobola, Intellectual Property Counsel at Aristocrat Technologies, Inc., discussed her experience as in-house counsel at a large corporation and her dealings with IP issues, including trademark licensing and Internet domain name matters.

The second event, a panel discussion on November 4, 2014, featured two attorneys practicing in Nevada who discussed the impact of recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions on the general practice of IP law, and IP law practice in Nevada in particular. Robert C. Ryan, a partner at the Holland & Hart Reno office, shared his story of personal involvement in the seminal U.S. Supreme Court case of Parker v. Flook, which he worked on while he was a law student, and discussed in detail the Court’s June 2014 decision in Alice v. CLS Bank, which has had a profound effect on patent applicants seeking to protect their computer-implemented inventions. John Brown, Of Counsel at Holland & Hart’s Las Vegas office, offered his view as an attorney who advises companies throughout their business cycles on a variety of issues that often include IP or intersect with IP matters. Students learned how the uncertainty about the effects of recent U.S. Supreme Court IP decisions affects startups, established businesses, and investors who might consider investing in IP-focused ventures.

The two events were co-organized by Associate Professor Marketa Trimble, an IP faculty member at Boyd, and the Boyd Career Development Office.

Professors LaFrance and Trimble Present at the 3rd Annual U.S.-China IP Conference

(From left) Professors Mary LaFrance and Marketa Trimble
On November 7, 2014, Professor Mary LaFrance and Associate Professor Marketa Trimble joined other IP law scholars at the 3rd Annual U.S.-China IP Conference at Loyola Law School, Los Angeles. The event was organized by Berkeley Law School’s Center for Law & Technology, Loyola Law School, and Renmin University of China. This year’s conference focused on the following five topics: (1) revisions to the copyright laws of the United States and China; (2) IP issues related to the entertainment industry; (3) the role of specialized IP courts; (4) patent and trade secrets legislation and protection; and (5) challenges and strategies in cross-border IP enforcement.

The Conference brought together senior policymakers, academics, and international practitioners from both the United States and China. Among the many prominent speakers were the following IP law experts:
  • Stacey Byrnes, Senior Vice President of NBC Universal/Universal Studios
  • Colleen V. Chien of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy
  • Liu Chuntian, Dean of Renmin University IP Academy
  • Mark Cohen of the USPTO
  • Professor Terry Fischer of Harvard Law School
  • Professor Robert Merges of Berkeley Law School
  • Professor David Nimmer of UCLA School of Law
  • Liu Ping of the Music Copyright Society of China
  • Professor Zhang Ping of Peking University Law School
  • Professor Seagull Song of Loyola Law School, Los Angeles
  • Maria Strong of the U.S. Copyright Office
  • Peter Yu of Drake Law School
Professor La France was invited to present “The Future of Performers’ Rights.” In her presentation she gave an overview of the current state of performers’ rights from the international law and comparative law perspectives. She then detailed the situation in the United States and explained how current U.S. law protects the moral and economic rights of performers. She concluded with the main features of the 1996 WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty and the 2012 WIPO Beijing Treaty on Audiovisual Performances, and by identifying how U.S. law might need to be amended to reflect U.S. obligations in the international treaties.

Professor Trimble was invited to participate in the panel discussion “Challenges and Strategies in Cross-Border IP Enforcement.” Her co-panelists were three practitioners from large international law firms, two Chinese academics, and a USPTO official. In the discussion Professor Trimble commented on the practical limitations of customs measures designed to stop infringing goods at country borders; she pointed out the high volume of goods coming through centralized points of entry such as the Port of Hamburg, and the limited resources of customs offices. Countries’ court proceedings should provide legal certainty and due process, and Professor Trimble emphasized the need for finality in cross-border IP enforcement, as shown in recent complex cross-border IP cases such as Microsoft Corp. v. Motorola, Inc. Professor Trimble also reported briefly on the activities of the International Law Association’s Committee on Intellectual Property and Private International Law, on which she serves.

Monday, February 10, 2014

Patent Litigation in Nevada (Part 4)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law 

This blog post follows my earlier posts about patent litigation in Nevada (here, here, and here) and introduces the judges and law firms who have been instrumental in patent litigation in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada in patent cases that were filed in 2010-2013.

Figure 1 shows the judges of the District Court who were assigned patent cases filed in 2010-2013 and the number of patent cases in their dockets. Judge Gloria Maria Navarro (whose chambers are in Las Vegas) is at the top of the chart; since her appointment in 2010 her caseload has included 33 patent cases that were filed in 2010-2013. Judge Robert Clive Jones (appointed in 2003, chambers in Reno) and Judge Miranda Mai Du (appointed in 2012, chambers in Reno) had the second-largest patent caseloads; each of their dockets included 25 patent cases that were filed in 2010-2013. Judges Navarro, Jones and Du, and Judge Philip M. Pro (appointed in 1987, chambers in Las Vegas) have been the designated Patent Pilot Program judges for the District Court since the Court joined the Program in 2011.

The Patent Pilot Program is designed to enhance the patent law expertise of judges participating in the Program by allowing them to hear more patent cases than they would otherwise hear without the Program. District Court judges who have not been designated Program judges may (but need not) decline to hear patent cases that have been assigned to them (cases are assigned to judges randomly); declined patent cases are then randomly assigned to the Program judges. The District Court is one of only 14 U.S. district courts that have been selected to participate in the Program; the courts selected include the major patent litigation federal district courts, such as the U.S. District Courts for the Eastern District of Texas, the Central District of California, and the Northern District of California.

Figure 2 shows the law firms that represented clients in patent cases that were filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada in 2010-2013; there were 167 different law firms that represented clients in the 133 patent cases that were filed in the District Court during that period. For visualization purposes Figure 2 includes data only for the 29 firms that represented clients in four or more cases during the period.

Firms that most often represented clients in patent cases filed in Nevada in 2010-2013 were, not surprisingly, law firms with offices in Nevada. The top five firms all had Nevada offices: Lewis and Roca LLP (since September 1, 2013, Lewis Roca Rothgerber LLP; offices in Las Vegas and Reno), Watson Rounds (Las Vegas and Reno), McDonald Carano Wilson LLP (Las Vegas and Reno), Lionel Sawyer & Collins (Las Vegas, Reno, and Carson City), and Gordon Silver (Las Vegas and Reno). Of the law firms without offices in Nevada, the firms that most often represented clients in patent cases were Finnegan, Henderson, Farabow, Garrett & Dunner, LLP; Kenyon and Kenyon LLP; Knobbe, Martens, Olson & Bear, LLP; and Bartlit Beck Herman Palenchar & Scott LLP.

The charts in this blog post were prepared based on data available in the Lex Machina database as of January 2014. 

Professor Trimble welcomes any citing or quoting of this blog post or reposting of the entire blog post and/or the figures; however, she requests that you cite the author and title of the blog post and include a link to this page.

Monday, February 3, 2014

Patent Litigation in Nevada (Part 3)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law

In my last blog post (here) I presented general data about patent cases filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada. In this post I will present data describing parties that were or are still involved in patent cases filed in the District Court in 2010-2013.

Because of the current nationwide interest in the “patent troll” phenomenon, which even featured in President Obama’s State of the Union Address last week (although disguised under the more general “innovation, not costly, needless litigation” theme), it is appropriate to begin an analysis of parties through the prism of this phenomenon. Patent trolls are persons or entities that own one or multiple patents and enforce their patent rights aggressively, sometimes using objectionable enforcement practices. Patent trolls are what “non-practicing entities” are often regarded as, because these entities own patents but do not manufacture any products or provide any services (other than the enforcement of patent rights). The latest term used to describe these kinds of entities is “patent-assertion entities.” In fact, no term captures well what the phenomenon represents, which remains subject to disagreements among commentators. Generally, critics accuse patent trolls of burdening “practicing” entities and the U.S. court system by filing suits against multiple defendants and enforcing patents of questionable validity. Patent troll defenders point out that trolls serve some positive functions in the patent landscape, that the U.S. patent system does not require patent owners to practice their own patents, and that the system does allow patent owners to enforce their own patents. Nevertheless, the phenomenon is a burden on the economy, and experts, industry representatives, the White House, and Congress are seeking ways to limit patent troll activity.

One way to search for patent trolls is to focus on “repeat plaintiffs” – parties that have filed multiple patent cases. For example, I looked for plaintiffs who filed patent cases in Nevada in 2010-2013 and were involved as plaintiffs in ten or more patent cases filed in any U.S. district court in 2000-2013. Based on these criteria I identified 22 plaintiffs; they filed 52 patent cases in Nevada in 2010-2013. Figure 1 shows that in 2010-2013 these repeat plaintiffs filed between 10 and 18 cases in Nevada each year, which was 50%, 33%, 31%, and 42%, respectively, of patent cases filed in Nevada in those years.

It would be a mistake to conclude that all repeat plaintiffs in Nevada are “patent trolls.” Out of the 22 different repeat plaintiffs, 16 (73%) were practicing entities that typically are not considered to be patent trolls: seven were pharmaceutical companies and nine were other practicing entities, such as Nike, Inc., Koninklijke Philips N.V., and Robert Bosch LLC. Six out of the 22 repeat plaintiffs do appear to fit some definition of patent troll – they seem to be non-practicing entities that specialize in patent enforcement. These six plaintiffs filed a total of nine lawsuits in Nevada in 2010-2013, meaning 7% of all patent cases filed in Nevada during that period.

Repeat plaintiffs are not always patent trolls, and patent trolls are not always repeat plaintiffs; new patent trolls may emerge that have not yet filed many lawsuits, and old patent trolls may have changed their names or spun off different subsidiaries. Depending on the definition of patent troll, patent trolls filed between 20 and 27 lawsuits in Nevada in 2010-2013, which is 15-20% of all patent suits filed in Nevada during that period. These percentages are substantially lower than the nationwide percentages suggested by various empirical studies; for example, according to some studies, in 2012 “patent assertion” or “non-practicing entities” filed between 50% (here) and 62% (here) of patent cases in U.S. district courts (cf. 25% in Nevada in 2012).

As for the domicile of parties that are involved in patent litigation in Nevada, Figure 2 shows that not all cases filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada involve parties that reside, are incorporated, or have their principal place of business in Nevada. In 2010, 50% of cases filed that year did not involve any parties from Nevada, and only 25% of cases were filed against a Nevada party (including cases in which multiple parties were sued and a Nevada party was one of them). Of the cases filed in 2013, 84% involved Nevada parties, and 30% were filed against a Nevada party or multiple parties that included a Nevada party.

Figure 3 shows foreign-country domiciles. For the purposes of the statistics reported here, each case was coded for the domicile of the parties involved in the case; each case was coded only once for each country represented among plaintiffs and among defendants. Green columns represent countries’ appearances on the plaintiffs’ side and red columns represent countries’ appearances on the defendants’ side. Parties from 18 foreign countries were involved in patent cases filed in Nevada in 2010-2013. Most of the cases (72%) had U.S. parties involved on both sides of the dispute—either U.S. parties only or U.S. parties together with foreign parties. In 26% of the cases one side of the dispute involved only foreign parties, and in two cases there were only foreign parties on both sides of the dispute. Of course it is important to note that the statistics in Figure 3 do not provide a perfectly accurate picture of the global nature of patent litigation because some parties with a global presence were acting through their U.S. subsidiaries.

The charts in this blog post were prepared based on data available in the Lex Machina database as of January 2014. 

Professor Trimble welcomes any citing or quoting of this blog post or reposting of the entire blog post and/or the figures; however, she requests that you cite the author and title of the blog post and include a link to this page.

Monday, January 27, 2014

Patent Litigation in Nevada (Part 2)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law

In 2014 I will follow my earlier blog posts about patenting in Nevada (here and here) and patent litigation in Nevada (here) and discuss detailed statistics about patent litigation before the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada. I derived the data used in this and the following blog posts from the Lex Machina database (here), and the statistics that I compiled from the data reflect information available in the database as of January 2014.

Figure 1 compares the numbers of patent cases filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada in 2000-2013 (gray columns) with the numbers of patent cases filed in those years in U.S. district courts U.S.-wide, including in Nevada (orange columns, in hundreds of cases).

In 2013 the number of patent cases filed continued to rise after the growth in the numbers experienced in 2009-2012, and reached 6,112 cases filed U.S.-wide in 2013. This number was an increase of 13% from 2012 (when 5,420 cases were filed), an increase of 73% from 2011 (3,529 cases), and an increase of 125% from 2010 (2,714 cases). In other words, there were more than twice as many patent cases filed in the United States in 2013 than were filed in 2010.

The development in the numbers of patent lawsuits filed in Nevada was different although the numbers grew as well; the 2013 Nevada number (43 cases) was an increase of 34% from 2012 (when 32 cases were filed), an increase of 43% from 2011 (30 cases), and an increase of 54% from 2010 (28 cases). As Figure 1 shows, while the U.S.-wide numbers jumped substantially from 2011 to 2012, the Nevada numbers grew substantially from 2009 to 2010 (from 15 to 28 cases) and from 2012 to 2013 (from 32 to 43 cases).

Figure 2 shows the types of claims that were included in the patent lawsuits filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada in 2010-2013. Most of the cases were brought by patent holders who claimed that one or more of their U.S. patents were infringed (blue columns). A smaller number of cases were filed by pharmaceutical companies as actions concerning new drug applications by producers of generic versions of patented drugs (“NDA/ANDA” actions; red columns). An even smaller number of cases were filed by persons or entities asking the court to declare that a patent was not valid and/or that the persons and entities did not infringe the patent (green columns). Finally, one case included a claim of a false patent marking – a claim that the defendant had provided incorrect patent information about its product (purple column).

The data in Figure 2 are rather typical for the U.S. patent litigation landscape, although the numbers of NDA/ANDA actions might be surprising because Nevada is not perceived as a center of the pharmaceutical industry. In 2012 NDA/ANDA actions represented 16% of patent cases filed in Nevada, while this type of action represented, for example, only 5% of all patent suits filed in 2012 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware. However, it is important to remember that the percentage in Nevada translates into only a handful of cases (compared to 51 cases in Delaware). In 2013, four out of six NDA/ANDA actions filed in Nevada that year were filed i.a. against Watson Laboratories, Inc., which is a Nevada corporation and a subsidiary of Watson Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (now Actavis, Inc.) with its global headquarters in Ireland. Note that plaintiffs do not have to file patent lawsuits where defendants reside, are incorporated, or have their principal place of business, and one of my upcoming blog posts will analyze the origins of defendants who have been sued in Nevada.

Figure 3 confirms another general trend in the patent litigation landscape – that most patent cases settle (see, e.g., here). Frequently they do not enter the trial phase and settle either after the claim construction hearing (in which the meaning of a patent is clarified) or even earlier. Figure 3 shows that in Nevada the typical types of terminations of patent cases that were filed in 2010-2013 (of the cases that were terminated by January 2014) were voluntary dismissals by the plaintiff or stipulated dismissals. By January 2014, 96% of patent cases filed in Nevada in 2010 were terminated, 67% of cases filed in 2011, 63% of cases filed in 2012, and 40% of cases filed in 2013. 

The charts in this blog post were prepared based on data available in the Lex Machina database as of January 2014. 

Professor Trimble welcomes any citing or quoting of this blog post or reposting of the entire blog post and/or the figures; however, she requests that you cite the author and title of the blog post and include a link to this page.

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Patent Litigation in Nevada (Part 1)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law

In two recent blog posts I discussed patenting in Nevada – trends in the numbers of patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or by Nevada assignees (see here and here). In this and upcoming posts I will provide data on patent litigation in Nevada.

Figure 1 shows the numbers of all patent cases filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada in 2000-2012. In this period the numbers of patent cases filed each year oscillated between 15 cases (filed in 2000) and 35 cases (filed in 2006). In 2012, 32 patent cases were filed in the Court.

Click on the charts to view larger versions.
The development in Nevada was spared the extreme spike in the numbers of cases that the U.S. patent litigation landscape experienced in 2012 when 5,421 patent cases were filed in all U.S. federal district courts. Figure 2 illustrates the sudden increase in the number of U.S. patent cases, which climbed in the past three years from 2,711 in 2010 and 3,533 in 2011 to 5,421 in 2012.

The spike in the number of patent cases filed in the United States in 2012 has been blamed on the activity of “patent trolls” – entities, also called “non-practicing entities” or “patent assertion entities,” that use questionable practices to enforce patents that they often did not obtain on their own inventions or their employees’ inventions but that the entities purchased from third parties. Some sources estimate that “patent trolls” filed as many as 62% of all patent cases in the United States in 2012 (see here). While the term “patent troll” has been used for several years, the phenomenon of entities accumulating patents on inventions invented by others and engaging in questionable enforcement practices has existed for decades. However, the prominence of “patent troll”-filed lawsuits in 2012 was unprecedented and generated a wave of intense interest in the problem among academics, research institutions, industry groups, Congress, and the White House (see, e.g., an article about the “anti-patent troll” bills before Congress here, a June 2013 White House report here, and an August 2013 CRS Report here).

It is difficult to create precise statistics on “patent troll” activities because opinions tend to differ about which persons and entities should be labeled as “patent trolls.” Based on the opinions of various commentators about the nature of the activities of some of the plaintiffs filing patent suits in Nevada, Nevada has also been affected by “patent troll” activity; however, the effects in Nevada appear to be less severe than in the United States overall. In 2012, the year which has been considered so far as the peak of “patent troll” activity in the United States, four out of the 32 patent cases filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada were filed by entities that have been referred to by some commentators as “patent trolls.” In 2011, out of a total of 30 cases, five cases were filed in Nevada by entities referred to by some commentators as “patent trolls.” Of course, these numbers are only estimates; as has been pointed out, disagreements exist as to when the designation of “patent troll” is warranted.

The statistics for this post were derived from data provided by LexMachina, Inc.

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Patenting in Nevada (Part 2)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law

In my blog post last week about Patenting in Nevada (here) I reported statistics showing the steep growth in the numbers of utility and design patents (see definitions of the two types of patents here) granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or on applications by Nevada assignees. This post will put the Nevada numbers in the larger U.S. context.

Click on the chart to view a larger version.
The rapid growth in 1976-2012 in the numbers of utility and design patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or on applications by Nevada assignees shown in the previous post (here) is illustrated in Figure 1 by blue and green trend lines, while the red line follows the trend in the growth of all U.S. utility and design patents granted in the same period (in thousands of U.S. utility and design patents). The comparison of the trend lines in Figure 1 shows that the trend in the growth of the numbers of utility and design patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or on applications by Nevada assignees was much steeper than the overall trend in the growth of all U.S. utility and design patents. In 2012 about 13 times more utility and design patents were granted than in 1976 for inventions invented by or co-invented by at least one Nevada inventor (from 87 in 1976 to 1,135 in 2012), and about 66 times more utility and design patents were granted than in 1976 on applications owned by Nevada assignees at the time of the publication of the applications (from 20 in 1976 to 1,317 in 2012). For all U.S. utility and design patents about 3.7 times more utility and design patents were granted in 2012 than in 1976.

Click on the chart to view a larger version.
The positive trend in the numbers of utility and design patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or on applications by Nevada assignees evidences the dramatic increase in the absolute numbers of such patents in 1976-2012. However, it is important to view the numbers in the context of the overall growth that Nevada experienced in the past two decades in population and economy.

Figure 2 shows that when calculating utility patents per million inhabitants, the trend in the growth of the numbers of Nevada utility patents granted in 1992-2012 followed the overall U.S. trend but that the Nevada numbers of utility patents granted per million Nevada inhabitants were consistently lower than the U.S. national numbers. Figure 2 focuses on utility patents that are designated by the USPTO as having a Nevada origin, meaning utility patents that had a Nevada inventor listed on the patent application as the only inventor or as the first co-inventor. The number of Nevada utility patents per million Nevada inhabitants is compared to the number of U.S. utility patents (U.S. inventor only or the U.S. co-inventor listed first) per million U.S. inhabitants. In 2012, about 273 utility patents were granted per million Nevada inhabitants on applications in which a Nevada inventor was listed as the only inventor or the first co-inventor; in the same year, about 386 utility patents were granted per million U.S. inhabitants on applications in which a U.S. inventor (from any U.S. state or territory, including Nevada) was listed as the only inventor or the first co-inventor.

Click on the chart to view a larger version.
Figure 3 shows that even when the numbers of utility patents are calculated per billion dollar GDP, the trend in the numbers of Nevada utility patents followed the national trend in 1997-2012 but that the numbers of utility patents granted per billion dollar Nevada GDP were also consistently lower than the U.S. national numbers. In 2012, about 5.6 utility patents were granted per billion dollar Nevada GDP on applications in which a Nevada inventor was listed as the only inventor or the first co-inventor; the same year, about 9.3 utility patents were granted per billion dollar U.S. GDP on applications in which a U.S. inventor (from any U.S. state or territory, including Nevada) was listed as the only inventor or the first co-inventor.

While Nevada should be proud of its steep growth in the absolute numbers of utility and design patents granted on applications by at least one Nevada inventor or Nevada assignee (see Figure 1 above and figures in the previous post here), it lags behind the nation when its numbers of utility patents granted on inventions by local inventors per million inhabitants and per billion dollar GDP are compared to the per million inhabitant and per billion dollar GDP U.S. national numbers.

The statistics for this post were derived from the following sources:
USPTO Patent Full-Text and Image Database
Calendar Year Patent Statistics
Historical National Population Estimates (July 1, 1900 to July 1, 1999)
U.S. Census Bureau, Population
Economic Research, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Patenting in Nevada (Part 1)

By Marketa Trimble, Associate Professor of Law

Last year on the UNLV Law Blog I presented statistics concerning copyright litigation in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada (here and here); this year I will look at patents and patent litigation in Nevada.

In 2012 the attention on copyright litigation in Nevada arose from a series of copyright infringement cases filed by Righthaven LLC; this year patent protection is the subject of a nationwide public debate as a result of the culmination of the problems with “patent trolls” – entities, sometimes referred to as “non-practicing entities” or “patent assertion entities,” whose predatory patent enforcement practices have burdened U.S. businesses for a number of years (see the June 2013 White House Report “Patent Assertion and U.S. Innovation” here).

The U.S. patent system also deserves attention this year for two other reasons: First, in March the long-discussed reform of the U.S. patent system became fully operational; among other changes, the reform changed the system of priority so that a patent is now granted to the inventor who first files a patent application in the U.S. Patent Office (previously, the first inventor would be granted a patent). Second, statistics suggest the beginning of a new era in which U.S. inventive activity will be exposed to increased competition from other countries. In 2008-2012, for the first time in U.S. history, more U.S. patents were granted in single calendar years on applications of non-U.S. inventors than on applications of U.S. inventors (based on the first inventor listed on an application; see the USPTO statistics here).

Patenting in Nevada has undergone tremendous growth in the past 40 years. Figures 1 and 2 below show the rapidly increasing numbers in 1976 – 2012 of U.S. utility and design patents granted for inventions by inventors and assignees from Nevada. Figure 1 shows the numbers of patents granted for inventions that were invented by a Nevada inventor or a group of inventors that included at least one inventor from Nevada. The numbers of patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors grew from 87 in 1976 to 1,135 in 2012. Figure 2 shows the numbers of patents granted on applications by Nevada assignees – individuals or entities in Nevada who owned a patent application at the time of its publication; those numbers grew from only 20 in 1976 to 1,317 in 2012. 

Click on the charts to view larger versions.
The steep growth in the absolute numbers of patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors and on applications by Nevada assignees implies a dramatically increased need for legal services in Nevada in the area of patent law. Graduates of the William S. Boyd School of Law are among the practitioners who provide such services in Nevada, and among the many talented students who enroll in Boyd are numerous prospective patent practitioners. In addition to students interested in transactional and litigation work in the intellectual property area, Boyd also has students interested in patent prosecution work – in the last five years Boyd enrolled five to eight students each year with engineering or science bachelor degrees that will likely make the students eligible to sit for the Patent Bar (the USPTO Examination for Registration to Practice in Patent Cases); some of the students have taken the Patent Bar during their law studies at Boyd. The engineering and science undergraduate majors represented among Boyd students in the past five years have been, for example, civil engineering, mechanical engineering, electrical engineering, computer engineering, chemistry, and biology. There have also been Boyd students with engineering and science graduate degrees; for example a doctorate in mechanical engineering and a doctorate in toxicology.

My next blog will place the Nevada patent statistics in a nationwide context by comparing national numbers to the numbers of utility and design patents granted for inventions by Nevada inventors or on applications by Nevada assignees.

The statistics for this post were derived from the following sources:
Elizabeth Jost, Admissions & Records Assistant, Boyd Admissions Office
USPTO Patent Full-Text and Image Database

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Professor Trimble Reviews Cotter's Comparative Patent Remedies: A Legal and Economic Analysis

The Boyd School of Law is very pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble recently reviewed Thomas F. Cotter's book Comparative Patent Remedies: A Legal and Economic Analysis (Oxford University Press 2013). 

Published on the Antitrust & Competition Policy Blog on April 30, 2013, Professor Trimble's review states that Comparative Patent Remedies "is an extremely timely and most welcome contribution to the comparative literature on intellectual property law and the law of remedies. . . .  In looking beyond U.S. borders, Cotter relies on his deep expertise in U.S. patent remedies from his previous publications. His knowledge enables him to detail a theoretical framework for remedies from a law and economics perspective (pp. 39-75), and it is within this framework that he presents his description and analysis of the law and practice of remedies in the United States (which covers slightly more than a fifth of the book – pp. 76-162), and several foreign countries, including the major patent litigation countries – the United Kingdom, Germany, and China. The coverage of countries is impressive because publications spanning this number of countries rarely appear in single-author monographs – they usually result from an international collaboration of several authors."  To read more of Professor Trimble's review, click here. 

Monday, April 22, 2013

Professor Trimble Guest Blogs on Patently-O

The Boyd School of Law is very pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble recently authored a guest blog post on Patently-O, the nation's leading patent law blog.

Titled "Patent-Conscious Preparation for a Summer at the Beach," Professor Trimble's guest blog post explains that as the America Invents Act slowly fades as a cocktail party topic, the topic of summer footwear presents opportunities for new patent-spirited discussions.  To read more about U.S. patent 8,371,043 and how it provides excellent material for discussion relating to U.S. intellectual property protection for fashion and the value of U.S. patents, click here.

Professor Trimble joined Boyd's full-time faculty in 2010, bringing expertise in Conflict of Laws, Patent Law, Cyberlaw, International Intellectual Property Law, Private International Law, Intellectual Property, Copyright Law, European Union Law, and Comparative Law. She is a graduate of Stanford Law School (J.S.D., 2010; J.S.M., 2006) and the Law School of Charles University in Prague (Ph.D., 2002; JUDr., 2001; and Mgr., 1997).

Monday, March 25, 2013

Recent Publications by Professor Trimble

The Boyd School of Law is pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble has several recent publications in the areas of intellectual property, international law, and gaming law.

First, Professor Trimble completed a book chapter titled "Proposal for an International Convention on Online Gambling."  This chapter, which will be published in Regulating Internet Gaming: Challenges and Opportunities (Ngai Pindell & Anthony Cabot eds., UNLV Gaming Press 2013), presents the outline of an international convention that will facilitate cooperation among countries in enforcement of their online gambling regulations while allowing the countries to maintain their individual legal approaches to online gambling.  A copy of Professor Trimble's chapter may be downloaded from SSRN here. 

Second, Professor Trimble completed an article titled "Injunctive Relief, Equity, and Misuse of Rights in U.S. Patent Law."  This article, published in 2012 by GRUR International, a law journal of the German Association for the Protection of Intellectual Property, discusses recent adjustments that U.S. courts have made to the doctrine of patent misuse and the availability of injunctive relief in patent infringement cases.  An abstract for the article is available from Scholarly Commons here.

Third, Professor Trimble updated and edited a book chapter titled "Extraterritorial Enforcement."  This chapter analyzes three forms of extraterritorial enforcement of intellectual property rights, including the extraterritorial application of intellectual property laws to acts committed outside protecting countries, the extraterritorial litigation of rights under the laws of foreign countries, and cross-border enforcement of judgments rendered in intellectual property cases.  This chapter will appear in Intellectual Property in Common Law and Civil Law (Toshiko Takenaka ed., 2013) later this spring.

Professor Trimble joined Boyd's full-time faculty in 2010, bringing expertise in Conflict of Laws, Patent Law, Cyberlaw, International Intellectual Property Law, Private International Law, Intellectual Property, Copyright Law, European Union Law, and Comparative Law. She is a graduate of Stanford Law School (J.S.D., 2010; J.S.M., 2006) and the Law School of Charles University in Prague (Ph.D., 2002; JUDr., 2001; and Mgr., 1997).

Monday, October 8, 2012

Professor Trimble Places Her Latest Article in the Emory International Law Review

The Boyd School of Law is very pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble placed her latest law review article ("GAT, Solvay, and the Centralization of Patent Litigation in Europe") in volume 26 of the Emory International Law Review. The article discusses the recent judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in Solvay v. Honeywell and its potential impact on the possibility of concentrating the litigation of multiple countries’ patents in a single national court.

As background, concentrating patent litigation that involves parallel patents in a single national court would improve the enforcement of patent rights by lowering litigation costs and enhancing the consistency of judgments concerning patents covering the same invention in multiple countries. However, any concentration of patent litigation is difficult because of the rule mandating that only courts in the country where a patent was granted may adjudicate the validity of the patent. In the European Union, the 2006 judgment in GAT v. LuK appeared to solidify this notion by holding that the exclusive jurisdiction rule, now in Article 22.4 of the Brussels I Regulation, applies to any decision on patent validity. However, the recent decision in Solvay opens the interesting possibility that preliminary assessments of patent validity could be made even by courts outside the country of the patent grant. Professor Trimble's article thus discusses whether Solvay could be extended to cover the assessments of validity that German courts conduct in infringement proceedings. If Solvay were to apply to these assessments, German courts could become the natural centers of litigation of infringements of multiple countries’ patents in Europe.

The full text of Professor Trimble's article may be downloaded from SSRN.

Professor Trimble joined Boyd's full-time faculty in 2010, bringing expertise in Conflict of Laws, Patent Law, Cyberlaw, International Intellectual Property Law, Private International Law, Intellectual Property, Copyright Law, European Union Law, and Comparative Law. She is a graduate of Stanford Law School (J.S.D., 2010; J.S.M., 2006) and the Law School of Charles University in Prague (Ph.D., 2002; JUDr., 2001; and Mgr., 1997).

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Professor Trimble Guest Blogs at Patently-O


The Boyd School of Law is very pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble recently guest blogged at Patently-O, the nation's leading patent law blog. Her blog post is entitled, "Solvay v. Honeywell and an Alternative Route to a Central Patent Court in Europe."

As background, the Court of Justice of the European Communities ("ECJ") left some crucial questions unanswered when, in 2006, it clarified the rules of jurisdiction in the European Union ("EU") as they pertained to patent litigation. In her blog post, Professor Trimble explains that the recent judgment of the ECJ in Solvay v. Honeywell (C-616/10, July 12, 2012) provides some additional answers and, most importantly, suggests that there could be a new route open for a central patent court in Europe. According to Trimble, "A possibility that such a court could informally emerge deserves attention, particularly because of the protracted and complicated negotiations surrounding the creation of a centralized patent court system in Europe, which have generated significant skepticism about the viability of the project as presented by the EU institutions."

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

UNLV to Host the Intellectual Property Conference 2012

The Boyd School of Law is very pleased to announce that the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, will host the Intellectual Property Conference 2012 on November 2, 2012.

The conference, which is presented by the Intellectual Property Law Section of the State Bar of Nevada, will include an opening "Year in Review" session presented by Boyd Professors Mary LaFrance and Marketa Trimble, a "Patent Topic" session by Mikio Ishimaru, Esq., a keynote address by Judge Philip M. Pro, a "Trademark Prosecution Tips" session by Paul Gast, Esq., another "Patent Topic" session by Jason Smalley, Esq., a "Copyright Topic" session by Kate Spelman, Esq., another "Patent Topic" session by Robert Ryan, Esq., and an ethics session entitled, "Don't Try This at Home: Why You Should Never Emulate TV Lawyers" by Sean Carter, Esq.

The conference, which will offer 6.5 continuing legal education credits, of which 2.0 may count as ethics credits, will be held in the Stan Fulton Building at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, on November 2, 2012, between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. Registration and other information is available here.


Monday, August 13, 2012

Professor Trimble Guest Blogs at Goldman's Technology & Marketing Law Blog


The Boyd School of Law is pleased to announce that Professor Marketa Trimble is guest blogging at Eric Goldman's Technology & Marketing Law Blog.

Professor Trimble's recent post, The Newest Olympic Sport: Evasion of Geolocation, characterizes the evasion of geolocation as primarily an expatriate sport; that is, a sport for those who long for their home television programming and other content on the internet that can be accessed only from inside their home country. By misleading the geolocation tools that website operators have installed, expatriates travel virtually to an internet IP address int heir home country to access their home television programs. In her post, Professor Trimble explains that those damaged by the new Olympic sport of geolocation evasion will be copyright holders who have licensed their content in a territorially limited manner. Professor Trimble concludes that although the evasion of gelocation may not immediately damage International Olympic Committee ("IOC") revenues, it may in the long run necessitate a rethinking of IOC licensing strategies.

Professor Trimble joined Boyd's full-time faculty in 2010, bringing expertise in Conflict of Laws, Patent Law, Cyberlaw, International Intellectual Property Law, Private International Law, Intellectual Property, Copyright Law, European Union Law, and Comparative Law. She is a graduate of Stanford Law School (J.S.D., 2010; J.S.M., 2006) and the Law School of Charles University in Prague (Ph.D., 2002; JUDr., 2001; and Mgr., 1997).

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Professor Trimble Publishes Global Patents: Limits of Transnational Enforcement


In today’s globalized economy, many inventors, investors and businesses want their inventions to be protected in many, if not most, countries. However, there currently exists no single patent that will protect an invention globally, and despite the attempts in international treaties to simplify patenting, the process remains complicated, lengthy, and expensive. Furthermore, the necessity of enforcing patents in multiple countries exists without any possibility of concentrating in one location any parallel proceedings that concern the same invention and the same parties, thus making the maintenance of parallel patents infeasible.

Professor Marketa Trimble’s recent book, Global Patents: Limits of Transnational Enforcement, explains why the absence of a "global patent" persists, and discusses the events in the 140-year history of patent law internationalization that have shaped the solutions. Professor Trimble analyzes the ways in which patent holders attempt to mitigate the problems that arise from the lack of global patent protection. One way is to concentrate enforcement in one court of patents granted in multiple countries, which makes the enforcement of the patents less costly and more consistent. Another way is to attempt to use the litigation of a single country patent to reach acts that occur outside the country, which can mitigate the lack of patent protection outside the country. However, both the concentration of proceedings and extraterritorial enforcement suffer from significant limitations. Global Patents explains these limitations and presents the solutions that have been proposed to address them. Professor Trimble’s book includes a thorough comparative analysis of the extraterritorial features of U.S. and German patent laws, and original statistics on U.S. patent litigation. Based on a comprehensive treatment of the various facets of transnational enforcement challenges, Professor Trimble proposes the next stage of patent law internationalization.

Full Citation: Marketa Trimble, Global Patents: Limits of Transnational Enforcement (Oxford University Press 2012). ISBN13: 9780199840687.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Professor Trimble Guest Blogs at JINÉ PRÁVO


The Boyd School of Law is very pleased that Professor Marketa Trimble has been invited to guest blog at JINÉ PRÁVO during the month of November. Her posts, all in Czech, include a post on "gaming law" and teaching "gaming law" in law schools, a post on possible reforms of U.S. legal education, and a post on cross-border problems in patent law, including a link to Professor Trimble's upcoming book on the topic. We look forward to Marketa's informative blogging on a wide range of topics!